CO129-115 - Sir MacDonnell - 1866 [9-10] — Page 263

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

3

262

and is the result of the labor of the

Committee

appointed by the Public meeting mentioned in my Despatch 152 of the 27th

August.

As the memorialists dwell much

J.

then

representing

the

"

enormity

of

the

Severe Community

as

a majority of

sinces

few, some

signing first directly for themselves -

and again for themselves through their

agents

and

employés.

It is not too much to say that, if I had proposed a tax on Houses, and the leading mercantile firms

had, in lieu thereof, suggested a Stamp

duty,

some 150 of the unwilling signatures

would have been appended to a demand for a Stamp law.

I trust it will not seem

invidious, if I remark, that although,

on the 17th of last month, they have had nearly

four

weeks to

get up their

Case,

the

enclosed bears 112 signatures less than the

Memorial, whilst the influence

of a few leading houses here commands

so many signatures of parties immediately dependent on them, that a document

like the enclosed is in a

great

measure

a reiteration of the opinions of comparatively

...

This is perhaps

a result

inseparable

from the preparation of almost any memorial here, and is only alluded to because the Memorialists treat the number of signatures

as a

leading argument. Once used as such it must be weighed and tested like other arguments.

4.

In

fact

that

argument has been

Edit History

2026-05-19 11:48:57 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
3 262 and is the result of the labor of the Committee appointed by the Public meeting mentioned in my Despatch 152 of the 27th August. As the memorialists dwell much J. then representing the " enormity of the Severe Community as a majority of sinces few, some signing first directly for themselves - and again for themselves through their agents and employés. It is not too much to say that, if I had proposed a tax on Houses, and the leading mercantile firms had, in lieu thereof, suggested a Stamp duty, some 150 of the unwilling signatures would have been appended to a demand for a Stamp law. I trust it will not seem invidious, if I remark, that although, on the 17th of last month, they have had nearly four weeks to get up their Case, the enclosed bears 112 signatures less than the Memorial, whilst the influence of a few leading houses here commands so many signatures of parties immediately dependent on them, that a document like the enclosed is in a great measure a reiteration of the opinions of comparatively ... This is perhaps a result inseparable from the preparation of almost any memorial here, and is only alluded to because the Memorialists treat the number of signatures as a leading argument. Once used as such it must be weighed and tested like other arguments. 4. In fact that argument has been
Baseline (Original)
3 262 and is the result of the labor of the Committe appointed by the Public meeting encntioned in my Despatele 152 of the 27th Allime. As the memorialists divell much J. then repissenting. the " enermen the Se Community av majuity of sinces few, soko sign-first sign first directly for themselves - and again for themselves through their a genti cents and to and employés. It is not too much "way that, if thad propord a lax-on Houses, and the leading mercantile firms had, in lien there of, suggested a Stamp duly some 150 of the winchim signatures would have been appended to a demand for a Hamp lave.. I list it wil not seem invidions, if I remant, that although, the 17th of last monch, they have had nearly fau weeks to get up their Case), the enclosed bears 112 signatures less than the Memorial, whilst the influence original of a few leading houses here commandh so many signatures of parties immediatity dependent, on them, that a document like the enclosed is in a great measure a reituration of the opinions of comparatiely 3. This is prehrases a.... result Vinseparable from the preparation of almost any memorial here, and is only alluded to because the Memorialets treat the number of signatures A leading argument. Once used as such it must be rosighed and tested lide other arguments. 4. In fact that argument has been
2026-05-19 11:48:57 · Baseline
View content

3

262

and is the result of the labor of the

Committe

appointed by the Public meeting encntioned in my Despatele 152 of the 27th

Allime.

As the memorialists divell much

J.

then

repissenting.

the

"

enermen

the

Se Community

av

majuity of

sinces

few, soko

sign-first

sign first directly for themselves -

and again for themselves through their

a genti

cents and

to

and employés.

It is not too much

"way that, if thad propord a lax-on Houses, and the leading mercantile firms

had, in lien there of, suggested a Stamp

duly

some 150 of the winchim signatures

would have been appended to a demand for a Hamp lave..

I list it wil not seem

invidions, if I remant, that although,

the 17th of last monch, they have had nearly

fau

weeks to

get up their

Case),

the

enclosed bears 112 signatures less than the

Memorial, whilst the influence

original

of a few leading houses here commandh

so many signatures of parties immediatity dependent, on them, that a document

like the enclosed is in a

great

measure

a reituration of the opinions of comparatiely

3.

This is prehrases

a....

result

Vinseparable

from the preparation of almost any memorial here, and is only alluded to because the Memorialets treat the number of signatures

A

leading argument. Once used as such it must be rosighed and tested lide other arguments.

4.

In

fact

that

argument has been

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.